What States Are At Will States: Know Your Rights

What states are at will states? It’s a common question with an answer that impacts workers’ compensation and employee rights. Employment law can be complex, so let’s clarify at-will employment and what it means for you.

Understanding at-will employment is vital for both employees and employers. It shapes the employment relationship, affecting rights, responsibilities, and expectations. In most U.S. states, employment is indeed “at-will,” but there are nuances.

What is At-Will Employment?

At-will employment means the employer can terminate employment for any legal reason, without needing “just cause.” Conversely, the employee can also leave at any time. This arrangement exists in every state except Montana. Many states have exceptions, including public policy exemptions and those based on implied contracts.

Federal laws provide additional protections for workers, impacting the at-will dynamic. At-will employment is not absolute, as many factors affect this status.

At-Will Employment and Workers’ Compensation

Many worry about being fired after a workplace injury. However, federal laws in all states prohibit an employer from firing an employee for filing a workers’ compensation claim. This includes filing a claim, reporting illegal activities, participating in an investigation, or receiving benefits. Such actions constitute illegal retaliation. If this happens, you may want to talk to a workers’ compensation lawyer about your workers comp claim.

Employers can still terminate employment for valid reasons unrelated to a workers’ compensation claim. Be sure you understand at-will employment laws in the context of employment contracts before reporting illegal activities.

Exceptions to At-Will Employment

Even in at-will states, some terminations are unlawful. Several exceptions exist to protect employees from wrongful termination, like being fired based on protected characteristics or for whistleblowing.

Public Policy Exception

Employees cannot be fired for actions that uphold public policy, including jury duty and reporting illegal activities. This exception prevents employers from forcing employees to violate public policy through illegal activities or ignoring federal laws.

Implied Contract Exception

An implied contract can create an exception. If an employer makes statements or establishes policies suggesting continued employment, an implied contract may exist, particularly for contract cases. Documents like employee handbooks or consistent employer practices can imply a contract.

Implied contracts provide certain job security and require “just cause” for termination, affecting employer ability to terminate employment.

Covenant of Good Faith and Fair Dealing Exception

Some states recognize a covenant of good faith and fair dealing in employment relationships, which provides job security. This means employers must act in good faith when terminating employees. Firing someone before receiving a bonus they earned could violate this covenant. There should always be valid reasons and never have it seem like there is an attempt to violate public policy.

Montana: The Exception

Montana is the only state that requires “just cause” for termination. Wrongful discharge occurs if the employer terminates employment without a “just cause” related to the employee’s work performance. Several exceptions exist in Montana’s “just cause” laws for specific contract situations, the probationary period, and similar cases.

Understanding At-Will by State

Most states operate under at-will employment, offering flexibility to employers and employees. However, exceptions like employment contracts, public policy considerations, implied contracts, or good faith covenants exist in various states. Understanding your state’s specific laws, federal laws, and company policies regarding firing, including any requirements for “just cause,” is crucial. It’s worth noting that policies can differ, especially during an employee’s probationary period. These exceptions cover instances such as an employer needing to terminate an employee but also the rights the employee has during an at-will employment relationship.

State	At-Will?	Public Policy Exception	Good Faith Covenant	Implied Contract Exception
Alabama	Yes	No	Yes	Yes
Alaska	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes
Arizona	Yes	Yes	No	Yes
Arkansas	Yes	No	No	Yes
California	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes
Colorado	Yes	Yes	No	Yes
Connecticut	Yes	Yes	No	Yes
Delaware	Yes	Yes	No	Yes
Florida	Yes	Yes	No	Yes
Georgia	Yes	Yes	No	Yes
Hawaii	Yes	Yes	No	Yes
Idaho	Yes	Yes	No	Yes
Illinois	Yes	Yes	No	Yes
Montana	No	N/A	N/A	N/A

FAQs about what states are at will states

How many US states are at-will?

Forty-nine states and the District of Columbia have at-will employment laws.

What states can you fire without cause?

Every state except Montana allows employers to fire employees without “just cause,” barring illegal discrimination or retaliation. For example, in states like North Carolina, South Carolina, North Dakota, South Dakota, and West Virginia, you do not have to have cause to terminate an employee. Whereas in states like Kansas, there are legal guidelines in place to protect both parties involved in the employment relationship. In Rhode Island, you should consult the specific statutes relevant to wrongful termination. Be sure you fully understand the public policy exception or implied contract exception in relation to terminating employment before doing so.

What is the difference between at-will and right-to-work states?

At-will employment concerns the reasons for terminating employment. Right-to-work laws address union membership. These two concepts are distinct. Right-to-work focuses on an employee’s choice of whether to join or financially support a union.

What states are not right-to-work states?

The following states are not right-to-work states: California, Hawaii, Illinois, Maryland, Massachusetts, Minnesota, Nevada, New Jersey, New Mexico, New York, Oregon, Rhode Island, Vermont, and Washington. In these states, certain jobs may require union membership. This is separate from at-will employment. These states may also follow different legal frameworks. These frameworks may relate to aspects of termination like compensation structure or seniority.

Conclusion

Knowing what states are at will states is crucial for navigating the complexities of employment law, especially regarding workers’ compensation and job security. While most states follow the at-will doctrine, numerous exceptions exist, such as those provided by an employment contract. Each state defines its boundaries, so it’s essential to understand the rules where you live and work. Getting familiar with the specific laws, especially if an implied contract exists, or exceptions, which are part of implied contract cases, of your state and employment agreements provides clarity and empowers both employers and employees. This includes understanding federal laws as well as specific company policies.

Sharing is Caring: