How Many Times Can You Apply for Disability?

Facing a denial for disability benefits can feel like a huge setback, especially when you’re already dealing with health issues. It’s a tough spot, and you might be wondering, “how many times can you apply for disability?” It’s a common question, and the answer isn’t always straightforward, leaving many social security disability applicants feeling confused and overwhelmed by the application process.

You’re not alone in this struggle. The good news is that a denied application isn’t necessarily the final word from the Social Security Administration. So, how many times can you apply for disability really? Let’s walk through the possibilities and the steps involved.

Understanding Social Security Disability Benefits

Before discussing reapplying, it’s helpful to understand the programs offering social security disability benefits. The Social Security Administration (SSA) manages two primary disability programs. One is Social Security Disability Insurance (SSDI), a form of disability insurance.

SSDI provides benefits to you and certain family members if you have worked long enough and paid Social Security taxes. The other program is Supplemental Security Income (SSI). SSI makes payments to adults and children who meet specific medical and financial criteria, meaning they have disabilities or are blind and have income and resources below set limits.

Medical eligibility for security disability benefits is generally the same under both SSDI and SSI. The main difference lies in the non-medical requirements. For SSDI, the Security Administration looks at your work history and earned work credits, while for SSI, they assess your income and assets to determine financial need.

Information about your medical condition, including statements from your doctors and medical test results, is crucial for both programs. Some individuals might be eligible for both SSDI and SSI concurrently, depending on their circumstances. It is also important to understand how workers’ compensation benefits might affect your SSA disability payments if you are receiving both.

The First Time You Apply

Your first disability claim filing is a significant step. You will need to provide extensive information about your medical conditions, the healthcare providers you’ve seen, and your complete work history. The SSA will use this data to determine if you meet their definition of disability, a critical factor to qualify disability status.

According to the SSA, “disability” means you cannot perform work that you did previously due to your medical condition. They also consider whether you can adjust to other types of work because of your condition. Your disabling condition must also be expected to last for at least one year or result in death for a disability claim to be considered.

The SSA uses a guide known as the Blue Book (or SSA Blue Book) which lists medical conditions qualify for disability benefits if they meet specific severity criteria. Even if your condition isn’t listed or doesn’t precisely meet a listing in the SSA Blue Book, you may still qualify if your overall limitations prevent you from working. Many disability applicants find assistance from family, friends, or advocates during the initial claim filing to ensure thoroughness, as missing information can cause delays or lead to a denied disability outcome.

Why Do Applications Get Denied?

It’s a difficult reality, but many initial disability claims are denied. The SSA’s 2022 Annual Statistical Report on the Social Security Disability Insurance Program indicates that denial rates can be substantial. There are numerous reasons why claims denied by the Social Security Administration occur.

Sometimes, the denial is due to a technical issue. Perhaps you lacked sufficient work credits for SSDI. Or, your income or assets were too high for SSI eligibility. These are non-medical reasons for denial of a social security disability claim.

Frequently, however, denials are for medical reasons. The SSA might conclude your condition isn’t severe enough to prevent all substantial gainful activity (SGA). They might believe it won’t last a full year, or they might think you can still perform some kind of work, even if it’s not your past job, perhaps even after a severe car accident or motorcycle accident.

Another common reason for a security disability claim denial is insufficient medical evidence presented. If your medical records do not clearly demonstrate how your condition limits your functional abilities, your claim might be denied. This highlights why comprehensive and consistent medical records are so important when seeking disability benefits.

The SSA also verifies if you are following your doctor’s prescribed treatment. If not, they might infer your condition isn’t as serious as stated, or that it could improve with adherence to medical advice. This assessment isn’t always fair, as treatment can be expensive or have severe side effects, but it is a factor they consider.

What Happens After a Denial? The Appeals Process

So, you received a denial letter for your disability case. What now? This is where the disability appeals process begins. You usually have 60 days from the date you receive the letter to request an appeal; paying close attention to this deadline is critical.

There are several levels in the SSA appeals process, which function as a step appeals process for your disability appeals:

1. Reconsideration

This is the first step at the appeals level. You ask the SSA to conduct a case review of your application again. Someone new, who was not involved in the initial decision, will review your file for your reconsideration appeal.

You can also submit any new medical evidence you have gathered since you first applied. For many security disability applicants, a reconsideration feels like a repeat of the initial application, and the outcome is often another denial. However, it’s a necessary step you generally cannot skip if you wish to continue appealing a denied appeal.

Some states participate in a prototype program that eliminates the reconsideration step for most medical denials, sending you directly to a hearing with an Administrative Law Judge.

2. Hearing by an Administrative Law Judge (ALJ)

If your reconsideration is denied, you can request an ALJ hearing with an Administrative Law Judge. This is a significant step in the review process. You have the opportunity to speak directly to the judge, either in person or sometimes by video conference, and explain how your disability affects your daily life and ability to work.

You can bring witnesses, such as medical experts or individuals familiar with your daily struggles. The ALJ hearing is often seen as your best chance to have your claim approved. The ALJ will examine all your evidence, listen to your testimony, and potentially question vocational or medical experts provided by the SSA’s medical examiners team before making a new decision. Many people who were denied at earlier stages find success at this level, especially if they have experienced disability representation.

3. Appeals Council Review

If the ALJ denies your claim, you can ask the Appeals Council to review that decision. The Appeals Council looks for legal or procedural mistakes the ALJ might have made in applying the law. They generally do not review new evidence unless it directly pertains to why you believe the ALJ’s decision was incorrect.

The Council can agree with the ALJ, decide in your favor, or send your case back to an ALJ for another hearing. It’s important to note that the Appeals Council reviews many cases but only remands or reverses the ALJ decision a small percentage of the time when an appeal reaches this stage.

4. Federal Court Review

If the Appeals Council does not rule in your favor or decides not to review your case, your last option within the SSA’s administrative disability appeals process is to file a lawsuit in a federal district court. This federal court review means a federal judge will examine your disability case. This step often requires significant legal knowledge and preparation.

Going to federal court for a court review can be a lengthy and complex process. The court primarily examines whether the SSA followed its own rules and regulations and if the decision was supported by substantial evidence in the record.

Here is a summary of the appeals stages:

Appeal Level	Description	Key Focus
1. Reconsideration	The SSA reviews the disability claim again with a new examiner.	Review of the existing file; new evidence presented can be added.
2. ALJ Hearing	A hearing before an Administrative Law Judge (ALJ).	Opportunity to present testimony, bring witnesses, and submit new evidence; often involves vocational and medical experts.
3. Appeals Council	Reviews the ALJ’s decision for legal or procedural errors.	Focuses on errors of law by the ALJ; limited new evidence accepted.
4. Federal Court Review	A lawsuit is filed in a U.S. federal district court.	Assesses if the SSA followed its own rules and if the decision was based on substantial evidence.

This structured approach to SSA appeals provides multiple opportunities for a review of your security disability claim.

So, How Many Times Can You Apply for Disability Benefits?

Now we address the central question: how many times can you apply for disability benefits? For brand new, initial applications, there isn’t a legislated limit. You can technically file claims again if a previous one was denied and you did not appeal, or if you completed the entire disability appeals process and were still denied.

However, there are crucial considerations. If you file claim after file claim for the same condition after being denied, and nothing significant has changed, the SSA might not view it favorably. They could see it as merely trying again without new, compelling reasons, especially if you are among many social security disability applicants trying to get benefits today.

If your condition has genuinely worsened, if you have substantial new medical evidence, or if a significant amount of time has passed since your last denial (making the period of disability different), then filing a new application might be a reasonable course of action. Also, if you have developed a new medical condition that causes disability, you can definitely file a new social security disability claim.

For the appeals council and other stages within the appeals process for a single claim, you generally only get one opportunity at each level. For example, if your reconsideration is denied, you appeal to an ALJ. If the ALJ denies your claim, you appeal to the Appeals Council. You progress up the ladder for that specific disability claim.

Starting Over: Filing a New Claim Versus Appealing

If your disability claim is denied, you face a choice: appeal the decision or file claim anew. Sometimes, filing a new application is more advantageous than pursuing an appeal. Other times, appealing is the recommended path to take if your claim denied status is to be overturned.

When might filing a new disability claim be a sound idea?

• Your medical condition has significantly worsened since the last decision was made on your previous disability case.
• You have a new, distinct medical condition that also severely limits your ability to work, potentially arising from a personal injury or other cause.
• A substantial period has passed since your previous application was denied, and you now possess more robust medical evidence supporting your current disability claim filing.
• Your prior claim was denied for a technical, non-medical reason (like insufficient work credits) that has since been rectified.
• You missed the critical deadline to appeal your last denial, leaving a new application as your primary option for seeking disability.

It is important to understand that if you file a new application while an appeal is still possible on a prior claim, the SSA might treat the new application in a particular way. They could even dismiss it if it’s for the same issue and time period as the claim you could still appeal. Often, it’s better to complete the SSA appeals process for one claim before initiating a completely new one for the exact same issues.

Appealing is usually the suggested route if you believe the SSA made an error in their decision on your existing disability claim, or if you have new evidence that supports your original application period. Appealing keeps your original application date active, which can be very important for security disability applicants. If you win your appeal, your security disability benefits might be backdated to this earlier date. If you file a new application, your benefits generally can only start from around the time of the new application (or sometimes a bit earlier for SSDI), meaning you might lose out on past-due benefits you could have received by successfully appealing.

Tips for When You Reapply or Appeal

Each time you interact with the SSA, whether it’s for disability appeals or a new application, you want to present the strongest possible disability case. Consider what might have been lacking previously. First, thoroughly understand why your denied application occurred; the denial letter should explain the reasons. This is your guide for what to address if you are seeking disability benefits again.

If they stated there wasn’t enough medical evidence, then obtaining more comprehensive medical records and reports is crucial. Gather more evidence by requesting copies of all your medical records and making sure they are current. Ask your doctor to write a detailed statement about your condition; this statement should explain your diagnosis, your symptoms, how your condition limits your ability to perform daily activities, and specifically how it prevents you from working. Specifics from medical examiners or your treating physicians are far more impactful than general statements.

Keep very detailed records of everything related to your disability claim. Note every doctor visit, test, and treatment. Maintain copies of all correspondence you send to and receive from the SSA. Being organized can significantly impact the review process.

Think carefully about your daily activities, as the SSA will inquire about what you can and cannot do. Be honest and realistic; do not exaggerate, but also do not understate your limitations. Sometimes, keeping a journal for a week or two can help you recall all the ways your condition affects you, providing valuable details for your own memory and for explaining your situation.

If your condition changes, inform the SSA immediately. If it worsens, this constitutes important new information for your disability case. Consider obtaining legal counsel from disability lawyers or a disability attorney. Many disability attorneys from a reputable law firm offer a free case evaluation to discuss your options. An experienced disability lawyer can be invaluable during the appeals council stage or if your case requires federal court review.

The Mental and Emotional Side of Applying

Dealing with a disability is inherently challenging. Undergoing the application process and, if necessary, the disability appeals process can add substantial stress and frustration. It’s easy to feel discouraged, especially if your disability claim is denied initially.

Remember that many individuals who are eventually approved for social security disability benefits were denied at first. A denial does not mean your condition isn’t serious or that you do not deserve assistance. The system simply has many intricate rules and requirements that must be met.

Try to find robust support systems. Friends, family, or support groups can offer significant help. Simply discussing what you’re experiencing can make a difference. Focus on what you can control, such as gathering your medical records and keeping the SSA updated on your condition. Try not to expend too much energy worrying about elements you cannot control, like the duration of the review process for your SSA disability application.

View this as a marathon, not a sprint. Be patient with yourself and with the process. Every step you take, whether it’s obtaining more medical records, preparing for an ALJ hearing, or consulting with disability lawyers, is a step forward in seeking disability solutions.

FAQs

Conclusion

So, how many times can you apply for disability? The answer is you can file claims by submitting an initial application multiple times. However, simply filing over and over without a change in your condition, new evidence presented, or a different legal argument is not likely to lead to your claim approved. The disability appeals process has specific, sequential steps, and you generally get one chance at each of those steps for a particular social security disability claim.

If your appeal reaches the end of the step appeals process and is still denied, or if your circumstances change significantly (such as a worsening condition or a new disabling impairment), you might consider filing a new application. The most important thing is to focus on building the strongest disability case you can each time, supported by solid medical evidence and a clear understanding of why you qualify disability status. It’s a difficult path, but understanding the process and your options can make it a little less overwhelming for all disability applicants trying to get benefits today.

Sharing is Caring: